TV News LIES

Monday, May 05th

Last update07:00:51 AM GMT

You are here News Politics Why the Right-Wing's Approach to Reading the Constitution Is Destroying This Country

Why the Right-Wing's Approach to Reading the Constitution Is Destroying This Country

E-mail Print PDF

New originalism eschews a focus on original intent and instead concentrates on the public meaning of the Constitution. Yet, if one looks carefully at the murky methodology and dubious practices of new originalism, it is clear that its historical foundations are even shakier than that of old originalism. The new theory is little more than an intellectual shell game in which contemporary political preferences are shuffled around and made to appear part of the Constitution’s original meaning.

New originalists are dismissive of history. They argue that original meaning, as they construe it, is simply different from historical meaning. If this claim were true, then historians would have no special expertise when it comes to understanding the original meaning of the Constitution. This view is utter nonsense. Different historical methods can certainly yield different answers to the question of what the Constitution meant. Social historians might give preference to what ordinary Americans thought the Constitution meant, while legal or constitutional historians might lay greater stress on the opinions of legal and judicial elites. It might well be the case that there was no consensus in the Founding era on what a specific provision of the Constitution meant. What is clearly false is the new originalist claim that original meaning is not subject to the rules of verification that apply to all historical works.

More...


Most Recent Related Stories...


Trump blocks grant funding for Harvard until it meets president’s demands

Ttrump blocks Harvard grants The US Department of Education informed Harvard University on Monday that it was ending billions of...

NYU Demands Law Students Renounce Protests or Be Barred From Sitting Final Exams

NYU LawNew York University School of Law barred 31 pro-Palestine law school students from campus facilities and...

GOP Rep. Mike Lawler's Town Hall Devolves Into Chants Of 'Shame! Shame! Shame!'

LawlerFrustrated voters turned out Sunday to voice their complaints against President Donald Trump’s administration during Republican...

Trump says he doesn’t know if he needs to uphold constitutional due process

Trump not sure about due process Donald Trump said “I don’t know” when asked if he needed to uphold the US constitution...
 
America's # 1 Enemy
Tee Shirt
& Help Support TvNewsLIES.org!
TVNL Tee Shirt
 
TVNL TOTE BAG
Conserve our Planet
& Help Support TvNewsLIES.org!
 
Get your 9/11 & Media
Deception Dollars
& Help Support TvNewsLIES.org!
 
The Loaded Deck
The First & the Best!
The Media & Bush Admin Exposed!